Index funds vs active funds: the rules and the cost difference
An index fund must invest at least 95% of its assets in the securities of the index it tracks, and its base expense ratio is capped at 0.90%. An active fund's manager picks securities within the category's rules, with a higher expense limit that depends on the scheme's size. Neither type promises a return; the cost difference is the part you can measure in advance.
SEBI, AMFI and Income-tax Department sources listed below, checked 17 November 2026An index fund aims to match its index, less costs. How closely it does so is shown by its tracking error and tracking difference, which schemes disclose for both the direct and regular plans.
An active fund aims to beat its benchmark through the manager's choices. Its result, after expenses, can be above or below the benchmark in any period. SEBI requires every scheme to show its benchmark and the benchmark's riskometer, so you can compare.
Worked example
₹1,00,000 invested once plus ₹10,000 a month for 20 years, at an assumed 12% a year before expenses. At a 0.5% expense ratio the investment grows to ₹1,02,21,725; at 1.5% it grows to ₹89,12,591. A gap of 1 percentage point a year costs ₹13,09,133, or 12.8% of the final value, on ₹25,00,000 invested.
Questions to ask before choosing
- What index or category does the scheme follow, and does it suit your goal and time horizon?
- What is the total expense ratio of the plan you would buy? Enter it in the calculator.
- For an index fund: how large are the tracking error and tracking difference?
- For an active fund: how has it done against its own benchmark over full market cycles, after expenses? Past figures do not predict future ones.
Index funds and active funds under SEBI's rules
| Index fund or ETF | Active fund | |
|---|---|---|
| Investment rule | At least 95% in the securities of the index tracked | Per its category, e.g. at least 80% in large caps for a large cap fund |
| Maximum base expense ratio | 0.90% | By scheme size: from 2.10% on the first ₹500 crore (equity) down to 0.95% above ₹50,000 crore |
| How many per fund house | One per index tracked | One per category |
| Extra disclosure | Tracking error and tracking difference | Benchmark and portfolio |
| ELSS version | Passive ELSS on an index of the top 250 companies | Active ELSS |
| Tax | As per fund type (equity-oriented if 65% in Indian listed shares) | As per fund type |
Questions people ask
Are index funds safer than active funds?
No. An index fund falls when its index falls. Its risk is that of the index, shown on its riskometer.
Is an ETF the same as an index fund?
Both track an index. An ETF's units are listed and traded on a stock exchange through a demat account; an index fund is bought from and sold to the fund house at NAV.
Is a lower expense ratio always better?
For two schemes tracking the same index, the lower cost plan usually keeps more of the index return. Across different schemes, cost is one factor among the strategy, the risk and the tracking quality.
Official sources
- SEBI, Master Circular for Mutual Funds as on 20 March 2026, checked 17 November 2026.
- SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 2026, in force from 1 April 2026, as last amended on 10 October 2026, checked 17 November 2026.
Calculators and related pages
- SEBI expense ratio limits
- SEBI fund categories
- Lumpsum vs SIP
- Stock market calculators
- What a demat account is
More mutual fund guides
- How to start a SIP and complete KYC
- Direct vs regular plan
- Expense ratio and SEBI limits
- Exit load
- NAV and cut-off times
- Capital gains tax on mutual funds
- ELSS and the 3-year lock-in
- Missed SIP instalments
- Nominee rules
- CAS statement
- Riskometer and SEBI categories
- IDCW vs growth and IDCW tax
- All mutual fund guides
For information only, not investment advice. We do not recommend any scheme or fund house. Rules change: check the scheme documents and your own tax position before you act.