Lumpsum vs SIP
Lumpsum or SIP for money you already have depends on what the market does while you are spreading it; at the default assumptions, investing it all at once wins by ₹39,716 over 10 years. This page is for a sum you have today, such as a bonus or a maturity amount: put it all in now, or feed it in over some months while the rest waits in a savings account. For a SIP out of your monthly salary there is no choice to make, and the SIP calculator is the tool.
Year-by-year figures
| Year | All at once | Spread as a SIP |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | ₹6,60,000 (6.60 lakh) | ₹6,43,157 (6.43 lakh) |
| 2 | ₹7,26,000 (7.26 lakh) | ₹7,07,472 (7.07 lakh) |
| 3 | ₹7,98,600 (7.99 lakh) | ₹7,78,220 (7.78 lakh) |
| 4 | ₹8,78,460 (8.78 lakh) | ₹8,56,041 (8.56 lakh) |
| 5 | ₹9,66,306 (9.66 lakh) | ₹9,41,646 (9.42 lakh) |
| 6 | ₹10,62,937 (10.63 lakh) | ₹10,35,810 (10.36 lakh) |
| 7 | ₹11,69,230 (11.69 lakh) | ₹11,39,391 (11.39 lakh) |
| 8 | ₹12,86,153 (12.86 lakh) | ₹12,53,330 (12.53 lakh) |
| 9 | ₹14,14,769 (14.15 lakh) | ₹13,78,663 (13.79 lakh) |
| 10 | ₹15,56,245 (15.56 lakh) | ₹15,16,530 (15.17 lakh) |
Side by side at the starting figures
| ₹6 lakh for 10 years | All at once | Spread over 12 months |
|---|---|---|
| Steady 10% a year | ₹15,56,245 | ₹15,16,530 |
| Market falls 20% in the first year, then 10% a year | ₹11,31,815 | ₹12,81,837 |
| Money not yet invested earns | Nothing waiting | 4% (post office savings rate) |
Starting figures: ₹6 lakh, spread in 12 equal monthly parts, held 10 years. Returns of 10% a year are an assumption. Money waiting earns the post office savings account rate of 4% for October to December 2026; a bank savings account may pay less. Tax is left out because both routes buy the same investment.
Break-even point
Spreading over 12 months wins only if the market returns less than 4.0% over the first year. When all the money is in by month 12, both routes are fully invested from then on and grow the same, so the whole difference comes from the first year: the market against the interest on money waiting. If the market falls 20% in that year, spreading wins by ₹1,50,023. Nobody can know the first year in advance, which is why spreading is a way to reduce regret rather than a way to earn more.
What changes the answer
All at once less spread, after 10 years on ₹6 lakh, by the first year's market return and the months you spread over.
| First-year return | Spread 6 months | Spread 12 months | Spread 24 months |
|---|---|---|---|
| -30% | Spread by ₹87,254 | Spread by ₹2,07,303 | Spread by ₹3,24,461 |
| -20% | Spread by ₹64,711 | Spread by ₹1,50,023 | Spread by ₹2,24,941 |
| -10% | Spread by ₹39,388 | Spread by ₹89,419 | Spread by ₹1,23,774 |
| 0% | Spread by ₹11,680 | Spread by ₹26,036 | Spread by ₹21,231 |
| 10% | At once by ₹18,108 | At once by ₹39,716 | At once by ₹82,487 |
| 20% | At once by ₹49,735 | At once by ₹1,07,519 | At once by ₹1,87,223 |
Trade-offs in plain English
| All at once | Spread as a SIP | |
|---|---|---|
| When it does better | When the market rises while you would have been spreading. | When the market falls soon after you start. |
| Risk of bad timing | All of it goes in at one price. | Purchases at several prices, so one bad day matters less. |
| Liquidity | Same once invested. | The part still waiting is in cash and easy to reach. |
| Effort | One transaction. | A standing instruction or a systematic transfer plan from a liquid or debt fund. |
| Tax | Gains taxed when sold. | Same; each instalment has its own purchase date for the holding period. |
How the comparison works
All at once: the sum is invested on day one and grows monthly at the first-year return for 12 months and at the later return after that. Spread: an equal part is invested at the start of each month for the months you choose; the rest earns the savings rate until it is invested. Values are compared at the end of the period.
With the same return every year the arithmetic always favours putting money in sooner, as the lumpsum calculator and SIP delay cost calculator show. The first-year input lets you test a fall or a rise.
Common mistakes
- Comparing a ₹6 lakh lumpsum with a ₹5,000 monthly SIP over 10 years. Those put in different amounts at different times. Compare the same money, as here.
- Leaving the waiting money in a current account. It earns nothing, which makes spreading cost more.
- Spreading for years. The longer the spread, the more of your money sits in cash; test 24 or 36 months above.
- Stopping the SIP when the market falls. That is when spreading helps; stopping turns it into poor timing.
Sources
- Ministry of Finance office memorandum of 30 September 2026 on small savings rates for October to December 2026: post office savings rate checked 14 November 2026
- SEBI investor website: mutual funds and the securities market checked 17 November 2026
Every return, growth rate and tax rate on this page is an assumption you can change, not a forecast. No return is guaranteed, market-linked investments can lose value, and this page does not suggest any fund or product.
Work out each side on its own
Terms on this page explained: lumpsum investment, SIP, SWP, mutual fund, CAGR, XIRR. More in the money terms glossary.
Other money decisions
- Money decisions
- Rent vs buy calculator
- Prepay home loan or invest
- PPF vs FD
- PPF vs ELSS vs FD
- NPS vs PPF
- FD vs debt mutual fund
- SCSS vs FD for senior citizens
- Personal loan vs credit card EMI
Questions people ask
Is lumpsum better than SIP?
For money you already have, investing all at once ends higher when the market rises during the months you would have spread; at a steady 10% it is ahead by ₹39,716 here. Spreading wins when the market falls early. Returns are not guaranteed either way.
What is an STP?
A systematic transfer plan keeps the sum in a liquid or debt fund and moves a fixed part into an equity fund each month. It works like the spread route here, with the waiting money in a fund instead of a savings account.
How many months should I spread over?
There is no right answer. 6 to 12 months is common; the table above shows what changes with a fall or a rise in the first year.
A tax professional can call you back. Asking is free.
Get helpMore calculators
Results are estimates for information only, not financial or tax advice. Rates, rules and limits change, so check with your bank, employer or a qualified adviser before you decide.