NPS vs PPF
NPS or PPF depends on the return NPS earns and on whether you want all your money free at 60; at the default assumptions, NPS builds ₹25.35 lakh more by 60, but 20% of the NPS corpus must buy a pension. PPF pays a government rate (7.1% for October to December 2026) and all of it is yours, tax-free, at maturity. NPS is market-linked, stays invested until 60 and then part of it must buy an annuity. The calculator saves the same amount each year in both.
| PPF | NPS | |
|---|---|---|
| You put in over 30 years | ₹15,00,000 (15.00 lakh) | ₹15,00,000 (15.00 lakh) |
| Value at 60 | ₹51,50,304 (51.50 lakh) | ₹76,85,309 (76.85 lakh) |
| Cash you can take at 60 | ₹51,50,304 (51.50 lakh) | ₹61,48,247 (61.48 lakh) |
| Locked into an annuity | ₹0 | ₹15,37,062 (15.37 lakh) |
| Extra tax saved (old regime) | ₹0 | ₹0 |
Year-by-year figures
| Age | PPF | NPS |
|---|---|---|
| ₹31 | ₹53,550 | ₹52,506 |
| ₹32 | ₹1,10,902 (1.11 lakh) | ₹1,09,937 (1.10 lakh) |
| ₹33 | ₹1,72,326 (1.72 lakh) | ₹1,72,756 (1.73 lakh) |
| ₹34 | ₹2,38,111 (2.38 lakh) | ₹2,41,467 (2.41 lakh) |
| ₹35 | ₹3,08,567 (3.09 lakh) | ₹3,16,624 (3.17 lakh) |
| ₹36 | ₹3,84,025 (3.84 lakh) | ₹3,98,832 (3.99 lakh) |
| ₹37 | ₹4,64,841 (4.65 lakh) | ₹4,88,751 (4.89 lakh) |
| ₹38 | ₹5,51,395 (5.51 lakh) | ₹5,87,105 (5.87 lakh) |
| ₹39 | ₹6,44,094 (6.44 lakh) | ₹6,94,685 (6.95 lakh) |
| ₹40 | ₹7,43,375 (7.43 lakh) | ₹8,12,357 (8.12 lakh) |
| ₹41 | ₹8,49,704 (8.50 lakh) | ₹9,41,067 (9.41 lakh) |
| ₹42 | ₹9,63,583 (9.64 lakh) | ₹10,81,852 (10.82 lakh) |
| ₹43 | ₹10,85,548 (10.86 lakh) | ₹12,35,843 (12.36 lakh) |
| ₹44 | ₹12,16,172 (12.16 lakh) | ₹14,04,279 (14.04 lakh) |
| ₹45 | ₹13,56,070 (13.56 lakh) | ₹15,88,516 (15.89 lakh) |
| ₹46 | ₹15,05,901 (15.06 lakh) | ₹17,90,035 (17.90 lakh) |
| ₹47 | ₹16,66,370 (16.66 lakh) | ₹20,10,459 (20.10 lakh) |
| ₹48 | ₹18,38,232 (18.38 lakh) | ₹22,51,560 (22.52 lakh) |
| ₹49 | ₹20,22,296 (20.22 lakh) | ₹25,15,277 (25.15 lakh) |
| ₹50 | ₹22,19,429 (22.19 lakh) | ₹28,03,733 (28.04 lakh) |
| ₹51 | ₹24,30,559 (24.31 lakh) | ₹31,19,249 (31.19 lakh) |
| ₹52 | ₹26,56,679 (26.57 lakh) | ₹34,64,362 (34.64 lakh) |
| ₹53 | ₹28,98,853 (28.99 lakh) | ₹38,41,848 (38.42 lakh) |
| ₹54 | ₹31,58,221 (31.58 lakh) | ₹42,54,746 (42.55 lakh) |
| ₹55 | ₹34,36,005 (34.36 lakh) | ₹47,06,376 (47.06 lakh) |
| ₹56 | ₹37,33,511 (37.34 lakh) | ₹52,00,373 (52.00 lakh) |
| ₹57 | ₹40,52,141 (40.52 lakh) | ₹57,40,709 (57.41 lakh) |
| ₹58 | ₹43,93,393 (43.93 lakh) | ₹63,31,733 (63.32 lakh) |
| ₹59 | ₹47,58,874 (47.59 lakh) | ₹69,78,200 (69.78 lakh) |
| ₹60 | ₹51,50,304 (51.50 lakh) | ₹76,85,309 (76.85 lakh) |
Side by side at the starting figures
| ₹50,000 a year from 30 to 60 | PPF | NPS |
|---|---|---|
| Return used | 7.1% (government rate) | 9% (assumption) |
| Value at 40 | ₹7,43,375 | ₹8,12,357 |
| Value at 50 | ₹22,19,429 | ₹28,03,733 |
| Value at 60 | ₹51,50,304 | ₹76,85,309 |
| Cash you can take at 60 | ₹51,50,304 | ₹61,48,247 |
| Locked into an annuity | None | ₹15,37,062, about ₹7,685 a month at 6% |
| Extra tax saved, old regime at 31.2% | None if 80C is already full | ₹15,600 a year, ₹4,68,000 in all |
Starting figures: ₹50,000 a year for 30 years. PPF takes it as one deposit each April, at the current rate throughout, extended in 5-year blocks after 15 years. NPS takes it as ₹4,167 a month at an assumed 9% a year, the middle of the 8% to 10% range on our NPS calculator. 20% of the NPS corpus buys an annuity at an assumed 6%. New regime, so no deduction.
Break-even point
NPS needs 7.04% a year to build the same corpus as PPF by 60. To give the same cash at 60 after setting aside 20% for the annuity, it needs 8.14% a year. Below those returns PPF wins on that measure; above them NPS does. In the old regime with 80C already full, the extra NPS deduction of up to ₹50,000 saves another ₹15,600 a year at 31.2% tax, which PPF cannot match.
What changes the answer
NPS corpus less PPF balance at 60, for ₹50,000 a year, by your age now and the NPS return.
| Age now | NPS 7% | NPS 8% | NPS 9% | NPS 10% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | PPF by ₹17,783 | NPS by ₹20.56 lakh | NPS by ₹47.83 lakh | NPS by ₹83.85 lakh |
| 30 | PPF by ₹37,439 | NPS by ₹11.01 lakh | NPS by ₹25.35 lakh | NPS by ₹43.47 lakh |
| 35 | PPF by ₹41,017 | NPS by ₹5.53 lakh | NPS by ₹12.7 lakh | NPS by ₹21.39 lakh |
| 40 | PPF by ₹36,240 | NPS by ₹2.51 lakh | NPS by ₹5.84 lakh | NPS by ₹9.71 lakh |
| 45 | PPF by ₹27,690 | NPS by ₹95,368 | NPS by ₹2.32 lakh | NPS by ₹3.85 lakh |
Trade-offs in plain English
| PPF | NPS | |
|---|---|---|
| Liquidity | Partial withdrawal from the 7th year; all of it at maturity. | Limited withdrawals before 60. At 60, at least 20% must buy an annuity (40% for government staff). |
| Lock-in | 15 years, then optional 5-year extensions. | Until 60 for normal exit. |
| Risk | Government rate, reset every quarter; no market risk. | Market-linked: equity, corporate bonds and government bonds, so the value can fall. |
| Tax | EEE: 80C in the old regime, and interest and maturity tax-free. | Extra deduction up to ₹50,000 in the old regime, beyond 80C. Employer contributions qualify in both regimes within limits. Part of the lump sum is tax-free; the pension is taxed as income. |
| What you get at 60 | One tax-free sum. | A lump sum plus a monthly pension for life from an insurer. |
How the comparison works
PPF: the yearly amount is deposited at the start of each year and compounded yearly at the rate you enter, as in the PPF calculator. NPS: the same yearly amount is paid in twelve monthly parts and grows monthly at the assumed return, as in the NPS calculator. The PPF deposit goes in earlier in each year, which gives it a small head start.
At 60, the annuity share of the NPS corpus buys a pension at the annuity rate you enter; the rest is the lump sum. The old-regime figure is the tax saved on up to ₹50,000 of NPS a year, for someone whose ₹1,50,000 80C limit is already used. It is shown separately and not added to either pot.
Common mistakes
- Comparing the NPS corpus with the PPF balance as if both were cash. At least 20% of NPS buys a pension, so compare the lump sum too: ₹61,48,247 against ₹51,50,304 here.
- Assuming the NPS return. 9% is a starting figure only. At 7% NPS ends at ₹51.13 lakh, against PPF's ₹51.5 lakh.
- Counting the extra deduction in the new regime. Your own NPS contribution gets the extra ₹50,000 only in the old regime.
- Putting money you may need before 60 into NPS. PPF allows partial withdrawals from the 7th year; NPS withdrawals before 60 are limited.
Sources
- PFRDA, National Pension System and the Exits and Withdrawals under NPS (Amendment) Regulations, December 2025 checked 16 November 2026
- Ministry of Finance office memorandum of 30 September 2026 on small savings rates for October to December 2026 checked 14 November 2026
- Income-tax Act, 2025 (in force from 1 April 2026): 80C and the extra NPS deduction, old regime checked 16 November 2026
Every return, growth rate and tax rate on this page is an assumption you can change, not a forecast. No return is guaranteed, market-linked investments can lose value, and this page does not suggest any fund or product.
Work out each side on its own
Terms on this page explained: NPS, PPF, Section 80C, old tax regime, UPS, EPF. More in the money terms glossary.
Other money decisions
- Money decisions
- Rent vs buy calculator
- Prepay home loan or invest
- PPF vs FD
- PPF vs ELSS vs FD
- FD vs debt mutual fund
- SCSS vs FD for senior citizens
- Personal loan vs credit card EMI
- Lumpsum vs SIP
Questions people ask
Which is better for retirement, NPS or PPF?
It depends on the return NPS earns and on how much you value certainty. At an assumed 9%, NPS builds ₹25.35 lakh more by 60. PPF is certain and tax-free, and all of it is yours at maturity. Many people use both.
Can I get the extra ₹50,000 deduction with PPF?
No. The extra deduction beyond the ₹1,50,000 80C limit is only for your own NPS contribution, and only in the old regime. PPF counts within 80C.
How much of NPS can I take as cash at 60?
Under PFRDA's exit rules amended in December 2025, non-government subscribers can take up to 80% as a lump sum and must use at least 20% for an annuity. Government employees keep the 40% minimum annuity. If the corpus is ₹8 lakh or less, the whole amount can be withdrawn.
A tax professional can call you back. Asking is free.
Get helpMore calculators
Results are estimates for information only, not financial or tax advice. Rates, rules and limits change, so check with your bank, employer or a qualified adviser before you decide.