PPF vs ELSS vs FD

The best 80C choice depends on how much ups and downs you can live with; at the default assumptions, ELSS comes first, ahead of PPF by ₹8.01 lakh over 15 years. All three count towards the ₹1,50,000 80C limit in the old regime. PPF pays a set rate tax-free, a tax-saver FD pays a set rate that is taxed every year, and ELSS is an equity fund whose return nobody can promise.

₹1,50,000 is the most 80C allows in the old regime.
15, or 20, 25, 30 with PPF extensions.
An assumption, not a promise. Returns can be lower or negative.
Your slab rate plus 4% cess: 5.2, 10.4, 15.6, 20.8, 26 or 31.2. Use 0 if your total income stays below the taxable limit.
After 15 years, ELSS comes first, ahead of PPF by
₹8,01,481 (8.01 lakh)
PPF (tax-free)₹40,68,209 (40.68 lakh)
ELSS after tax on gains₹48,69,690 (48.70 lakh)
FDs after tax₹35,40,993 (35.41 lakh)
ELSS return needed to match PPF7.80%
PPFELSSFD
You put in₹22,50,000 (22.50 lakh)₹22,50,000 (22.50 lakh)₹22,50,000 (22.50 lakh)
Value before tax₹40,68,209 (40.68 lakh)₹52,42,459 (52.42 lakh)Taxed every year
Tax at the endNone₹3,72,770 (3.73 lakh)Already paid
In hand after tax₹40,68,209 (40.68 lakh)₹48,69,690 (48.70 lakh)₹35,40,993 (35.41 lakh)
Year-by-year figures
YearPPFELSS before taxFD after tax
₹1₹1,60,650 (1.61 lakh)₹1,65,000 (1.65 lakh)₹1,58,224 (1.58 lakh)
₹2₹3,32,706 (3.33 lakh)₹3,46,500 (3.46 lakh)₹3,25,124 (3.25 lakh)
₹3₹5,16,978 (5.17 lakh)₹5,46,150 (5.46 lakh)₹5,01,174 (5.01 lakh)
₹4₹7,14,334 (7.14 lakh)₹7,65,765 (7.66 lakh)₹6,86,877 (6.87 lakh)
₹5₹9,25,701 (9.26 lakh)₹10,07,342 (10.07 lakh)₹8,82,762 (8.83 lakh)
₹6₹11,52,076 (11.52 lakh)₹12,73,076 (12.73 lakh)₹10,89,386 (10.89 lakh)
₹7₹13,94,524 (13.95 lakh)₹15,65,383 (15.65 lakh)₹13,07,340 (13.07 lakh)
₹8₹16,54,185 (16.54 lakh)₹18,86,922 (18.87 lakh)₹15,37,244 (15.37 lakh)
₹9₹19,32,282 (19.32 lakh)₹22,40,614 (22.41 lakh)₹17,79,753 (17.80 lakh)
₹10₹22,30,124 (22.30 lakh)₹26,29,675 (26.30 lakh)₹20,35,558 (20.36 lakh)
₹11₹25,49,113 (25.49 lakh)₹30,57,643 (30.58 lakh)₹23,05,389 (23.05 lakh)
₹12₹28,90,750 (28.91 lakh)₹35,28,407 (35.28 lakh)₹25,90,015 (25.90 lakh)
₹13₹32,56,643 (32.57 lakh)₹40,46,248 (40.46 lakh)₹28,90,245 (28.90 lakh)
₹14₹36,48,515 (36.49 lakh)₹46,15,872 (46.16 lakh)₹32,06,937 (32.07 lakh)
₹15₹40,68,209 (40.68 lakh)₹52,42,459 (52.42 lakh)₹35,40,993 (35.41 lakh)

Side by side at the starting figures

₹1,50,000 a year for 15 yearsPPFELSSTax-saver FD
Return used7.1% (government rate)10% (assumption)6.75% (IDFC FIRST)
Value before tax₹40,68,209₹52,42,459Taxed each year
TaxNone₹3,72,770 on selling20.8% of interest yearly
In hand after tax₹40,68,209₹48,69,690₹35,40,993
If ELSS returns only 6%₹40,68,209₹35,28,515₹35,40,993

Starting figures: ₹1,50,000 at the start of every year. ELSS return 10% a year is an assumption, not a forecast; units are all sold in year 15, with long-term gains taxed at 12.5% plus cess above ₹1,25,000. The FD rate is the highest 5-year general rate on the bank rate cards we track (IDFC FIRST Bank), renewed at the same rate, with interest taxed at 20.8%.

Break-even point

ELSS has to return 7.80% a year, every year, to match PPF after tax over 15 years. Above that it comes out ahead; below it PPF does. The tax-saver FD would need 8.68% to match PPF at 20.8% tax. Equity returns move a lot from year to year, so even an average above the break-even can leave you behind if the last few years are bad and you must sell then.

What changes the answer

Which comes first after 15 years at ₹1,50,000 a year, by ELSS return and your tax rate on FD interest.

ELSS returnTax 10.4%Tax 20.8%Tax 31.2%
4% a yearPPF, then FDPPF, then FDPPF, then FD
6% a yearPPF, then FDPPF, then FDPPF, then ELSS
8% a yearELSS, then PPFELSS, then PPFELSS, then PPF
10% a yearELSS, then PPFELSS, then PPFELSS, then PPF
12% a yearELSS, then PPFELSS, then PPFELSS, then PPF

Trade-offs in plain English

PPFELSSTax-saver FD
LiquidityPartial withdrawal from year 7; loan from year 3 to 6.Each instalment can be sold 3 years after it was bought.No early withdrawal for 5 years.
Lock-in15 years (extendable).3 years per instalment, the shortest of the three.5 years.
RiskGovernment scheme; the rate is reset each quarter.Equity: value can fall well below what you put in.Rate fixed for 5 years; DICGC cover up to ₹5 lakh per bank.
Tax on returnsNone.12.5% on long-term gains above ₹1,25,000 a year.Interest taxed at your slab every year.
80C in the old regimeYes, within ₹1,50,000.Yes, within ₹1,50,000.Yes, within ₹1,50,000.

How the comparison works

Each option gets ₹1,50,000 at the start of every year. PPF grows at its rate compounded yearly, as in the PPF calculator. ELSS grows at the return you enter and everything is sold at the end, with long-term capital gains tax worked out on the total gain less the yearly exemption. Selling over a few years can use the exemption more than once, so the true tax can be lower. The FD grows at its quarterly-compounded yield less yearly tax on the interest.

The 80C deduction is the same for all three, so it is not added to any side. In the new regime none of them gives a deduction, and the comparison is just about returns, risk and tax on the returns.

Common mistakes

Sources

Every return, growth rate and tax rate on this page is an assumption you can change, not a forecast. No return is guaranteed, market-linked investments can lose value, and this page does not suggest any fund or product.

Work out each side on its own

Terms on this page explained: PPF, ELSS, FD, Section 80C, LTCG, old tax regime, new tax regime. More in the money terms glossary.

Other money decisions

Questions people ask

Which is the best tax-saving investment under 80C?

None is best for everyone. PPF is set and tax-free; ELSS may earn more but can lose value; a tax-saver FD is set but taxed. At a 10% assumed ELSS return, ELSS ends highest. ELSS needs about 7.8% a year to match PPF.

Which has the shortest lock-in?

ELSS, at 3 years from each purchase. A tax-saver FD locks in for 5 years and PPF for 15, with partial withdrawals from the 7th year.

Is ELSS gain tax-free up to ₹1.25 lakh?

Long-term gains on equity funds, ELSS included, are tax-free up to ₹1,25,000 a year in total across all your equity sales. Above that the rate is 12.5% plus cess.

Need help with tax, GST or your accounts?

A tax professional can call you back. Asking is free.

Get help

More calculators

Results are estimates for information only, not financial or tax advice. Rates, rules and limits change, so check with your bank, employer or a qualified adviser before you decide.