Rent vs buy calculator

Rent or buy depends mostly on the rent compared with the home's price and on how fast prices rise; at the default assumptions, renting and investing leaves you ₹35.94 lakh richer after 20 years. Enter the home, the loan and the rent for a similar home. The calculator follows both households month by month: the buyer pays EMI and upkeep, the renter pays rent and invests the down payment and every rupee the buyer spends over the rent.

The home and the loan

Banks lend at most 75% to 90% of the price, so 10% to 25% is the least you pay.
Use the rate your lender quotes you.
Assumption: legal fees, loan processing fee, brokerage, moving and furnishing.

Renting, growth and returns (all assumptions)

An assumption. Prices can stay flat or fall for years.
An assumption, not a promise. Returns can be lower or negative.
Brokerage and fees when you sell, so both sides are in cash.
After 20 years, renting and investing leaves you richer by
₹35,93,560 (35.94 lakh)
Monthly EMI₹48,262
Cash needed on day one₹21,00,100 (21.00 lakh)
Stamp duty and registration₹5,25,100 (5.25 lakh)
Break-evenRenting stays ahead for all 20 years
BuyRent and invest
Cash out on day one₹21,00,100 (21.00 lakh)₹0
Housing cost in month 1₹51,387₹20,000
Paid for housing over 20 years₹1,28,22,911 (1.28 crore)₹79,35,829 (79.36 lakh)
Of which loan interest₹55,82,938 (55.83 lakh)₹0
Tax saved on the loan₹0₹0
Home value after selling costs₹1,97,00,735 (1.97 crore)₹0
Loan still owed₹0₹0
Investments₹0₹2,32,94,296 (2.33 crore)
Net worth at the end₹1,97,00,735 (1.97 crore)₹2,32,94,296 (2.33 crore)
Year-by-year figures
YearHome valueLoan leftNet worth if you buyNet worth if you rent
1₹78,75,000 (78.75 lakh)₹58,65,090 (58.65 lakh)₹19,31,160 (19.31 lakh)₹26,60,884 (26.61 lakh)
2₹82,68,750 (82.69 lakh)₹57,19,736 (57.20 lakh)₹24,66,327 (24.66 lakh)₹32,55,973 (32.56 lakh)
3₹86,82,188 (86.82 lakh)₹55,63,128 (55.63 lakh)₹30,32,237 (30.32 lakh)₹38,87,582 (38.88 lakh)
4₹91,16,297 (91.16 lakh)₹53,94,397 (53.94 lakh)₹36,30,737 (36.31 lakh)₹45,58,079 (45.58 lakh)
5₹95,72,112 (95.72 lakh)₹52,12,602 (52.13 lakh)₹42,63,788 (42.64 lakh)₹52,69,993 (52.70 lakh)
6₹1,00,50,717 (1.01 crore)₹50,16,733 (50.17 lakh)₹49,33,477 (49.33 lakh)₹60,26,026 (60.26 lakh)
7₹1,05,53,253 (1.06 crore)₹48,05,700 (48.06 lakh)₹56,42,020 (56.42 lakh)₹68,29,066 (68.29 lakh)
8₹1,10,80,916 (1.11 crore)₹45,78,330 (45.78 lakh)₹63,91,777 (63.92 lakh)₹76,82,199 (76.82 lakh)
9₹1,16,34,962 (1.16 crore)₹43,33,357 (43.33 lakh)₹71,85,255 (71.85 lakh)₹85,88,726 (85.89 lakh)
10₹1,22,16,710 (1.22 crore)₹40,69,418 (40.69 lakh)₹80,25,125 (80.25 lakh)₹95,52,176 (95.52 lakh)
11₹1,28,27,545 (1.28 crore)₹37,85,045 (37.85 lakh)₹89,14,224 (89.14 lakh)₹1,05,76,321 (1.06 crore)
12₹1,34,68,922 (1.35 crore)₹34,78,657 (34.79 lakh)₹98,55,576 (98.56 lakh)₹1,16,65,200 (1.17 crore)
13₹1,41,42,369 (1.41 crore)₹31,48,549 (31.49 lakh)₹1,08,52,396 (1.09 crore)₹1,28,23,130 (1.28 crore)
14₹1,48,49,487 (1.48 crore)₹27,92,884 (27.93 lakh)₹1,19,08,108 (1.19 crore)₹1,40,54,732 (1.41 crore)
15₹1,55,91,961 (1.56 crore)₹24,09,685 (24.10 lakh)₹1,30,26,357 (1.30 crore)₹1,53,64,954 (1.54 crore)
16₹1,63,71,559 (1.64 crore)₹19,96,818 (19.97 lakh)₹1,42,11,025 (1.42 crore)₹1,67,59,087 (1.68 crore)
17₹1,71,90,137 (1.72 crore)₹15,51,989 (15.52 lakh)₹1,54,66,247 (1.55 crore)₹1,82,42,800 (1.82 crore)
18₹1,80,49,644 (1.80 crore)₹10,72,721 (10.73 lakh)₹1,67,96,427 (1.68 crore)₹1,98,22,163 (1.98 crore)
19₹1,89,52,126 (1.90 crore)₹5,56,349 (5.56 lakh)₹1,82,06,256 (1.82 crore)₹2,15,03,674 (2.15 crore)
20₹1,98,99,733 (1.99 crore)₹0₹1,97,00,735 (1.97 crore)₹2,32,94,296 (2.33 crore)

Side by side at the starting figures

Starting figures, 20 yearsBuyRent and invest
Cash out on day one (down payment, stamp duty, other costs)₹21,00,100₹0 (invested instead)
Monthly cost in year 1₹51,387 (EMI plus upkeep)₹20,000 rent
Paid for housing over 20 years₹1,28,22,911₹79,35,829
Of which loan interest₹55,82,938None
Net worth after 5 years₹42,63,788₹52,69,993
Net worth after 10 years₹80,25,125₹95,52,176
Net worth after 20 years₹1,97,00,735₹2,32,94,296

Starting figures: a ₹75 lakh home in Delhi (male buyer, stamp duty and registration ₹5,25,100), 20% down, a 20-year loan at 7.48% (the middle of the starting rates published by the 10 lenders we track), rent of ₹20,000 a month (3.2% of the price a year) rising 5% a year, the home rising 5% a year, upkeep 0.5% of its value a year, 1% other buying costs, 1% selling costs, 8% after-tax return on investments, and the new tax regime. Every one of these is an assumption you can change above.

Break-even point

At the starting figures, renting and investing stays ahead in every one of the 20 years. With everything else unchanged, buying would draw level at 20 years if home prices rose 5.9% a year, or if the rent for a similar home were ₹24,291 a month (3.9% of the price a year).

In the old regime, in the 30% slab (31.2% with cess) and the full ₹1,50,000 of 80C free for the principal, the tax saved over the loan comes to ₹20,16,225, and after 20 years buying comes out ahead by ₹11.98 lakh. Most salaried people already fill 80C with EPF, so check your own room before counting the principal.

What changes the answer

Net worth after 20 years, buying less renting, as the home price rise and the starting rent change. Everything else stays at the starting figures.

Rent nowPrice rise 3%Price rise 5%Price rise 7%Price rise 9%
₹15,000 a monthRent ahead by ₹1.37 croreRent ahead by ₹77.81 lakhBuy ahead by ₹7.74 lakhBuy ahead by ₹1.31 crore
₹20,000 a monthRent ahead by ₹95 lakhRent ahead by ₹35.94 lakhBuy ahead by ₹49.61 lakhBuy ahead by ₹1.72 crore
₹25,000 a monthRent ahead by ₹53.12 lakhBuy ahead by ₹5.94 lakhBuy ahead by ₹91.48 lakhBuy ahead by ₹2.14 crore
₹30,000 a monthRent ahead by ₹11.25 lakhBuy ahead by ₹47.81 lakhBuy ahead by ₹1.33 croreBuy ahead by ₹2.56 crore

Trade-offs in plain English

BuyRent and invest
LiquidityMost of your wealth is in one asset. Selling takes months and costs brokerage and fees.Investments can usually be sold in days, in part or in full.
Lock-inThe loan runs for years. Moving city means selling or letting out the home.You can move at the end of the rent agreement, often 11 months.
RiskOne home in one area: prices can stay flat for years. The EMI may rise if a floating rate goes up.Rent can rise faster than you planned. Investment returns can be low or negative, and you may be asked to move.
TaxOld regime only: interest up to ₹2,00,000 a year on a self-occupied home and principal within 80C. Nothing in the new regime.HRA exemption in the old regime if your salary has HRA. Gains on investments are taxed when you sell.
DisciplineThe EMI forces saving: every month some of it repays the loan.Works only if you really invest the difference every month and leave it invested.

How the comparison works

The buyer pays the down payment, stamp duty and registration (from Delhi's rates, or the rate you type for another state) and other costs on day one. Each month the buyer pays the EMI (the same reducing-balance formula as the EMI calculator) plus upkeep, which is a share of the home's value that year. The renter pays the rent, which rises once a year.

Both households spend the same: the renter invests the day-one cash and, each month, whatever the buyer pays above the rent. When the rent is higher, as it often is after the loan ends, the buyer invests the difference. Investments grow at the after-tax return you enter, compounded monthly. In the old regime, the tax saved on interest (up to ₹2,00,000 a year) and on principal (within the 80C room you enter) is added to the buyer's investments at each year end.

Net worth for the buyer is the home's value less selling costs, less the loan still owed, plus investments. For the renter it is investments only. The break-even year is the first year from which buying stays ahead to the end. Capital gains tax on selling the home is left out, because a home you live in is rarely sold at a set date; see the capital gains tax page if you plan to sell.

Common mistakes

Sources

Every return, growth rate and tax rate on this page is an assumption you can change, not a forecast. No return is guaranteed, market-linked investments can lose value, and this page does not suggest any fund or product.

Work out each side on its own

Terms on this page explained: EMI, stamp duty, circle rate, LTV, HRA, old tax regime, floating interest rate. More in the money terms glossary.

Other money decisions

Questions people ask

Is it better to rent or buy a house in India?

It depends on the rent compared with the price, the rise in prices and rents, and what you would earn on the money instead. At 3.2% rent a year on the price, a 5% price rise and an 8% return, renting and investing comes out ₹35.94 lakh ahead after 20 years. Change the figures to your city and your loan offer.

What is a good rent to price ratio for buying?

There is no single rule. At the other starting figures here, buying draws level at 20 years when a year's rent is about 3.9% of the price. Where rents are a smaller share of prices, renting tends to win; where they are a larger share, buying tends to win.

Does the calculator include stamp duty?

Yes. Pick the state and the buyer, and stamp duty and registration are worked out from that state's rates on our stamp duty calculator, on the price you enter. For other states, choose "Other state" and type the rate.

Why does the renter invest the EMI difference?

So that both sides spend the same amount each month. Otherwise the comparison would reward whichever side simply spends less. If you would not invest the difference, renting will not build the wealth shown here.

Need help with tax, GST or your accounts?

A tax professional can call you back. Asking is free.

Get help

Related topics

More calculators

Results are estimates for information only, not financial or tax advice. Rates, rules and limits change, so check with your bank, employer or a qualified adviser before you decide.