Personal loan vs credit card EMI

A personal loan or a card EMI depends on the two rates, the fees and GST; at the default assumptions, the personal loan costs ₹4,386 less on ₹1 lakh over 12 months. Interest on a personal loan is exempt from GST; interest on a card EMI is not, so 18% GST is added to each month's interest and to the processing fee. The calculator works out both on the same reducing-balance basis.

3 to 60.
Use the rate the lender offers you.
18% GST is added on the fee.
From your card's EMI offer.
18% GST is added on the fee and on the interest.
The personal loan costs less by
₹4,386
Personal loan EMI₹8,792
Card EMI with GST in month 1₹10,493
Card rate at which both cost the same9.39%
Personal loanCard EMI
Interest₹5,499₹8,877
GST on interest₹0₹1,598
Fee with GST₹1,770₹1,180
Total extra you pay₹7,269₹11,655
Total paid back₹1,07,269 (1.07 lakh)₹1,11,655 (1.12 lakh)
Yearly cost of everything13.35%21.15%

Side by side at the starting figures

₹1 lakh for 12 monthsPersonal loanCard EMI
Rate10% (middle of 10 lenders' starting rates)16% (example)
Monthly EMI₹8,792₹9,073 plus GST on interest
Interest₹5,499₹8,877
GST on interestNone₹1,598
Processing fee with GST₹1,770₹1,180
Total paid back₹1,07,269₹1,11,655
Yearly cost of everything13.35%21.15%

Starting figures: ₹1,00,000 over 12 months. Personal loan at 10%, the middle of the lowest rates published by the 10 lenders we track (8.85% to 10.50%), with an assumed 1.5% processing fee plus GST. Card EMI at 16% with a 1% fee, the example figures on our credit card EMI calculator; issuers quote their own for each offer. Your own rate depends on your credit score and income.

Break-even point

With these fees, a card EMI costs the same as the personal loan when its rate is 9.39% a year. Below that the card EMI is cheaper; above it the personal loan is. A no-cost EMI offer, where the seller's discount covers the interest, can beat both, but GST on the interest and the fee is usually still yours to pay.

Personal loan starting rates by lender

Lowest published rate from each lender, and the EMI and total on ₹1 lakh over 12 months at that rate, before any fee. Your own rate may be higher.

LenderFromEMITotal before fee
Axis Bank8.85%₹8,738₹1,04,858
Union Bank of India9.15%₹8,752₹1,05,025
Canara Bank9.95%₹8,789₹1,05,471
Kotak Mahindra Bank9.99%₹8,791₹1,05,493
Bajaj Finance10.00%₹8,792₹1,05,499
State Bank of India10.00%₹8,792₹1,05,499
HDFC Bank10.25%₹8,803₹1,05,639
ICICI Bank10.25%₹8,803₹1,05,639
Bank of Baroda10.40%₹8,810₹1,05,722
Punjab National Bank10.50%₹8,815₹1,05,778

What changes the answer

Card EMI less personal loan, total cost, by amount and months, at the starting rates and fees.

Amount6 months12 months24 months
₹20,000Loan cheaper by ₹408Loan cheaper by ₹877Loan cheaper by ₹1,865
₹50,000Loan cheaper by ₹1,020Loan cheaper by ₹2,193Loan cheaper by ₹4,663
₹1 lakhLoan cheaper by ₹2,041Loan cheaper by ₹4,386Loan cheaper by ₹9,326
₹3 lakhLoan cheaper by ₹6,122Loan cheaper by ₹13,157Loan cheaper by ₹27,977

Trade-offs in plain English

Personal loanCredit card EMI
Speed and paperworkAn application, income proof and a credit check; money paid to your bank account.Converted from a purchase in a few clicks if your card offers it.
LimitSeparate from your card limit; amount set by the lender.Uses up your card limit until the EMIs are paid, which raises your credit utilisation.
CostInterest GST-free; fee plus GST.18% GST on every month's interest and on the fee.
Early closureOften allowed after some EMIs; check the foreclosure charge in the agreement.Check the issuer's EMI terms; any foreclosure charge carries GST.
If you miss a paymentLate fee and a mark on your credit report.The EMI is part of the minimum due; missing it makes the card account past due.

How the comparison works

Both use the reducing-balance EMI. For the card EMI, GST is added to each month's interest and to the fee, as on the credit card EMI calculator. For the personal loan, GST is added to the fee only. The yearly cost is the rate at which everything you pay, fee and GST included, equals the amount you received, times 12.

The break-even card rate is found by trying card rates until both totals are the same.

Common mistakes

Sources

Every return, growth rate and tax rate on this page is an assumption you can change, not a forecast. No return is guaranteed, market-linked investments can lose value, and this page does not suggest any fund or product.

Work out each side on its own

Terms on this page explained: EMI, processing fee, credit utilisation, minimum amount due, CIBIL score, GST. More in the money terms glossary.

Other money decisions

Questions people ask

Which is cheaper, a personal loan or a credit card EMI?

At the starting figures, the personal loan is cheaper by ₹4,386 on ₹1 lakh over 12 months. The card EMI has GST on its interest; the personal loan does not, but it may have a bigger fee.

Why is there GST on card EMI interest but not on loan interest?

Interest on ordinary loans is exempt from GST, but the exemption leaves out interest involved in credit card services, so card EMI interest is taxed at 18%.

Is no-cost EMI really free?

The bank still charges interest, and the seller gives a discount equal to it. GST on that interest and any processing fee are usually still charged to you.

Need help with tax, GST or your accounts?

A tax professional can call you back. Asking is free.

Get help

More calculators

Results are estimates for information only, not financial or tax advice. Rates, rules and limits change, so check with your bank, employer or a qualified adviser before you decide.