FD vs debt mutual fund

FD or debt fund depends on the fund's return against the FD rate and on how long you hold; at the default assumptions, the FD leaves you ₹15,345 more after 3 years. Debt funds bought from 1 April 2023 are taxed at your slab rate however long you hold them, the same rate as FD interest. The difference is timing: FD interest is taxed every year, a fund's gain only when you sell.

1 to 30.
An assumption, not a promise. Returns can be lower or negative.
Your slab rate plus 4% cess: 5.2, 10.4, 15.6, 20.8, 26 or 31.2. Use 0 if your total income stays below the taxable limit.
After 3 years, the FD leaves you more by
₹15,345
FD after tax₹6,04,462 (6.04 lakh)
Debt fund after tax₹5,89,117 (5.89 lakh)
Tax on the fund when you sell₹23,404
Fund return needed to match the FD8.12%
Year-by-year figures
YearFD after taxDebt fund after tax if sold
1₹5,32,643 (5.33 lakh)₹5,27,720 (5.28 lakh)
2₹5,67,417 (5.67 lakh)₹5,57,380 (5.57 lakh)
3₹6,04,462 (6.04 lakh)₹5,89,117 (5.89 lakh)

Side by side at the starting figures

₹5 lakh for 3 yearsBank FDDebt fund
Return used8% (Jana SFB, 3 years (1095 days))7% after costs (assumption)
When tax is paidEvery year on interest earnedOnce, when you sell
Tax rate20.8% (slab)20.8% (slab)
In hand after 3 years₹6,04,462₹5,89,117
Same rates over 10 years₹9,41,095₹8,82,992

Starting figures: ₹5 lakh for 3 years. FD rate: the highest 3-year general rate on the bank rate cards we track (Jana Small Finance Bank), compounded quarterly. Debt fund: an assumed 7% a year after the fund's expenses. Tax at 20.8% on both.

Break-even point

Over 3 years the debt fund needs 8.12% a year after costs to match the FD at 8%. The longer you hold, the more paying tax once at the end helps the fund: over 10 years at the same rates the gap is ₹58,103 in favour of the FD. A fund's return is not fixed, and in a year when bond prices fall its value can go down.

What changes the answer

FD less debt fund after tax, on ₹5 lakh at 8% FD and 20.8% tax, by fund return and years held.

Fund return1 year3 years5 years10 years
6%FD by ₹8,883FD by ₹28,820FD by ₹52,027FD by ₹1,27,919
6.5%FD by ₹6,903FD by ₹22,114FD by ₹39,410FD by ₹93,748
7%FD by ₹4,923FD by ₹15,345FD by ₹26,554FD by ₹58,103
7.5%FD by ₹2,943FD by ₹8,512FD by ₹13,455FD by ₹20,926
8%FD by ₹963FD by ₹1,616FD by ₹111Fund by ₹17,840

Trade-offs in plain English

Bank FDDebt mutual fund
LiquidityCan be broken early, usually at a lower rate and with a penalty set by the bank.Units can usually be sold on any working day; some funds charge an exit load for early exit.
Lock-inThe tenure you choose.None for most debt funds.
RiskRate fixed for the term. DICGC cover up to ₹5,00,000 per depositor per bank.No deposit insurance. Value moves with interest rates and with the credit quality of the bonds held.
TaxInterest taxed at your slab every year; TDS once interest from one bank passes ₹50,000 a year.Gain taxed at your slab when you sell, for units bought from 1 April 2023, whatever the holding period.
ReturnKnown on the day you invest.Not known in advance.

How the comparison works

FD: a cumulative deposit compounded quarterly. Tax is due on the interest as it is earned each year, so the deposit grows at its yearly yield less tax. Debt fund: it grows at the return you enter, and tax at your slab is taken once, on the whole gain, when you sell.

The break-even return is found by trying fund returns until both end at the same amount. FD maturity before tax uses the same formula as the FD calculator.

Common mistakes

Sources

Every return, growth rate and tax rate on this page is an assumption you can change, not a forecast. No return is guaranteed, market-linked investments can lose value, and this page does not suggest any fund or product.

Work out each side on its own

Terms on this page explained: FD, mutual fund, NAV, expense ratio, STCG, TDS, DICGC. More in the money terms glossary.

Other money decisions

Questions people ask

Are debt funds better than FDs after the tax change?

Both are now taxed at your slab rate. A fund can still come out ahead if its return after costs beats the FD, and because tax is paid only when you sell. At the starting figures the fund needs about 8.12% to match a 8% FD over 3 years.

Is a debt fund safe?

It is not insured and its value can fall when interest rates rise or when a bond it holds is downgraded. An FD is insured by DICGC up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank.

Does holding a debt fund longer lower the tax rate?

No. For units bought from 1 April 2023 the gain is taxed at your slab rate whatever the holding period. Holding longer only puts off the day the tax is paid, which is where the fund's small edge over an FD comes from.

Need help with tax, GST or your accounts?

A tax professional can call you back. Asking is free.

Get help

More calculators

Results are estimates for information only, not financial or tax advice. Rates, rules and limits change, so check with your bank, employer or a qualified adviser before you decide.